News

When it comes to staying fit and embracing an active lifestyle, both cycling and running are time-tested favorites. In Ireland, where the landscapes range from lush greenways to urban paths and rugged coastal routes, these two forms of exercise have passionate followings. But with the rise of electric bicycles (e-bikes) from brands like we offered at Pogo Cycles, the cycling vs. running debate takes on a new dimension. Let’s dive into the ultimate showdown, comparing cycling—including the e-bike revolution—and running across key dimensions like joint impact, calorie burn, accessibility, and more.

1. Joint Impact: Gentle Pedals vs. Pounding Pavements

Cycling has long been celebrated as a low-impact activity, and e-bikes take it a step further by reducing the strain even further. The smooth, repetitive motion of pedaling—with the added assistance of an e-bike motor—is easy on the joints, particularly the knees, hips, and ankles. For individuals with arthritis, previous injuries, or those recovering from surgery, e-bikes provide an excellent way to stay active without risking joint health.

In contrast, running is a high-impact activity. Each step delivers a jolt to the body, with forces up to three times your body weight impacting your knees and ankles. While this stress can strengthen bones and muscles over time, it’s also a leading cause of injuries such as shin splints, plantar fasciitis, and stress fractures—particularly for beginners or those running on hard surfaces like urban streets.

Winner: Cycling (especially with e-bikes), which is gentler on the joints and ideal for longevity. 

2. Calorie Burn: Pedaling vs. Pacing

When it comes to burning calories, running typically takes the lead. A 70kg individual can burn around 600 calories per hour running at a moderate pace (about 8km/h), while cycling at a moderate pace (15-20km/h) burns approximately 400 calories in the same time. However, with an e-bike, riders can extend their sessions and explore longer routes, which could equal or surpass the calorie burn of shorter, high-intensity runs.

Additionally, e-bikes allow users to adjust the level of motor assistance. By using lower assistance levels, riders can increase their physical effort, enhancing calorie burn while still enjoying the benefits of extended rides.

Winner: Running for quick calorie burn; e-biking for sustained, long-duration workouts with customizable effort.

3. Cardiovascular Health: Both Are Winners

Both cycling and running are excellent for improving cardiovascular fitness. Regular sessions of either activity strengthen the heart, improve circulation, and lower the risk of chronic diseases like hypertension and diabetes. E-bikes add a unique twist by encouraging longer rides, which can lead to greater overall cardiovascular benefits over time.

For Irish fitness enthusiasts, e-bikes provide an added incentive to explore scenic routes without the intimidation of steep climbs or long distances. This makes cycling more accessible and enjoyable for people who might otherwise be discouraged by traditional cycling.

Winner: A tie—both activities excel at boosting heart health, with e-bikes offering a more accessible entry point.

4. Accessibility and Environment: Tailored to Ireland’s Terrain

Ireland’s environment plays a significant role in determining the accessibility of cycling and running. The country is dotted with stunning routes like the Great Western Greenway, the Dublin Canal paths, and rugged coastal trails. Here’s how each activity fits:

• Cycling: E-bikes make it easier than ever to explore Ireland’s landscapes. With pedal-assist features, riders can conquer steep hills and long distances with minimal effort, making cycling a more inclusive activity. Greenways and bike lanes across Ireland are perfect for e-bike enthusiasts.
• Running: Running requires minimal equipment—just a good pair of shoes and the will to start. Urban parks, countryside paths, and even beaches offer ample opportunities. However, rainy weather and uneven rural trails can make running less appealing or more challenging at times.

Winner: E-biking for infrastructure and long-distance exploration; running for simplicity and minimal setup.

5. Muscle Engagement: Strength vs. Endurance

Running primarily targets the lower body—the calves, quads, hamstrings, and glutes—while also engaging the core for stability. Over time, it can lead to improved muscle endurance and tone.

Cycling, especially with e-bikes, emphasizes the quads, hamstrings, and glutes but also engages smaller stabilizing muscles. E-bikes allow riders to adjust resistance levels, providing options for both endurance and strength-building. Uphill climbs and long rides with minimal motor assistance can significantly improve muscle tone and strength.

Winner: Cycling (with e-bikes) for versatile muscle engagement; running for muscle endurance.

6. Mental Health and Stress Relief

Both cycling and running are excellent for mental health, helping to reduce stress, anxiety, and depression. The release of endorphins—those “happy hormones”—is a common benefit of both activities.

For many Irish fitness enthusiasts, e-bikes add an extra layer of mental relief by making cycling feel effortless and enjoyable. Imagine cycling through the lush landscapes of County Kerry or along the Cliffs of Moher on an e-bike —it’s a surefire way to rejuvenate the mind.

Winner: A tie, with e-bikes offering an added sense of freedom and ease.

7. Social Connectivity: Pedal Together vs. Run Alone

Cycling tends to be more social. E-bike group rides, such as those organized by local cycling clubs, are growing in popularity across Ireland. The ability to adjust motor assistance makes it easy for riders of different fitness levels to stay together and enjoy the journey.

Running, while also social at events like parkruns or races, is often a solitary pursuit. It appeals to those who enjoy alone time and introspection but can feel isolating for some.

Winner: Cycling (with e-bikes) for social connections; running for solitude seekers.

Final Thoughts: Choosing Your Champion

So, which is better—cycling or running? The answer depends on your goals, preferences, and physical condition. If you prioritize joint health, long-distance exploration, and social interaction, cycling—especially with an e-bike — is your best bet. If you’re after quick calorie burn, minimal equipment, and a high-intensity workout, running may take the crown.

For Irish fitness enthusiasts, the good news is that Ireland’s stunning landscapes and growing infrastructure support both activities. Whether you’re pedaling through the Connemara greenways on an e-bike or running along Dublin’s coastal paths, you’re bound to reap the rewards of an active lifestyle.

Why not enjoy the best of both worlds? Incorporating e-biking and running into your routine can provide a balanced, varied fitness program that keeps you motivated and healthy—all while soaking in the beauty of Ireland.